No before
Yes.

“No” is the first interesting word we say. Sure, parents get excited when a baby says “Mama” or “Dada” for the first time. But the first time a kid says “No!” — well, heads turn. From the very first time we say it, we discover the power of No. No makes space, it differentiates, it identifies. Chocolate can only be chocolate because it’s not vanilla or strawberry or Cherry Garcia.

No can imply yes, and yes can imply no. The answer to “Will you marry me?” implies Nos and Yeses: If I say yes, then I’m also saying no to sleeping with other people and host of other things I might have wanted to say yes to before I said yes to you. If I say no, then I’m saying yes to continuing my life as it is. By saying no to one thing, I say yes to others; and by saying yes to something, I foreclose other opportunities.

Which makes the relationship of No and Yes a little mysterious. Jewishly speaking, the idea that comes to mind is that of kedusha, usually translated as “holiness.” On one level, kedusha implies separation, saying no to unholy things. But that is a cold kedusha. A warmer version is the No to unholiness that is implied in a larger Yes to holiness. Just as two people can be married, avoid violating their commitment, but have a cold relationship, so too we can preserve the external form of our commitments by saying no, without a strong internal Yes that pulls us forward.

So what do you say no to? And just as important, do you say yes to other things?

Share this!

  • Add to Del.icio.us
  • Digg it!
  • Post to Technorati
  • Add to Blinklist
  • Add to furl
  • You reddit
  • Facebook
Share It!

What do you say no to?

Post a comment
  1. Emily: I say no to very little. To be honest, I don’t know whether that has a positive or negative influence on my life. On one hand, I am opening myself to a lot of new to experiences without limitation. On the other hand, I sometimes find myself ... Read more

  2. Anne: I say no to getting ahead on homework. I say no to practicing when I don’t feel like it. I say yes to eating Reeses peanut butter Christmas trees two months before Christmas, even though I’m forever trying to diet. I say no on ... Read more

  3. Rachel: It’s interesting to think about how the word ‘no’ truly means ‘yes’ to all of the converse effects of the question/concept. In general, I say no to very few concepts, but with the immediate exception of a concept ... Read more

  4. Courtney:

    I say no to (returning to) unhealthy relationships.

    I say yes to abandoning negativity, exploring my interests and helping others.

  5. rabbijosh: Check out this Thanksgiving article by Roger Cohen in the New York ... Read more

  6. Ashley:

    Mediocrity. It’s always important to strive for sometime both as an individual as well as a society. It’s important to aspire towards something and to work hard to achieve it.

Leave a Reply